12-Month Coffee Cake Club (Begins October 2020)

  • Sale
  • Regular price $45.00


12x flavor of the month cakes

1-year subscription for 2 lb. flavor of the month coffee cakes, shipped monthly on the first Wednesday of each month when you place your order prior to the 21st. Orders placed the 21st through the end of the month will have their 1st month ship within 48 hours using 2-day shipping.

Your order will begin with October's Pumpkin Spice Cheesecake coffee cake. 

Our 2 lb. cakes serve 5-8 people.



It's finally here! The classic 2 lb. coffee cake you know and love is now getting a monthly makeover. As a member of the coffee cake fan club, you will receive a curated cake each month featuring seasonal flavors nestled in the sour cream cake you know and love. 

Celebrate the little things each day with this special treat. Enjoy with coffee, tea, Big Lug beer, wine, or a tall glass of milk. 

Support local with a monthly gift to a friend, client, family, or of course, yourself!



Cake: Pumpkin spice cheesecake with cookie butter glaze

Ingredients: Sour cream, butter, cake flour, eggs, sugar, brown sugar, vanilla extract, pumpkin puree, pumpkin spice blend, cream cheese, milk, pumpkin seeds, rolled oats, salt, honey, maple syrup, baking powder, biscoff cookies

*produced in a facility that contains nuts*



THIS SUBSCRIPTION SAVES YOU $5/MONTH: Subscribing saves 10% on every order over buying each month a la carte!

CHOOSE TO PREPAY AND SAVE $15/MONTH: Pay for the whole year upfront and save 30% on every order over buying each month a la carte!

Typically, subscription orders ship the 1st Wednesday of every month and should arrive within 48 hours (just in time for the weekend).

Subscription billing occurs on the 15th of every month, paying for the order that will ship the following month. (EXAMPLE: Billing on October 15th will ensure you get November's order)

Minimum of 2 months fulfilled before subscription is eligible for cancellation.



October 2020

  • Pumpkin spice cheesecake with cookie butter glaze

November 2020

  • Caramel apple pie with cinnamon sugar coating 

December 2020

  • Figgy pudding with candied oranges and big lug stout

January 2021

  • Cherry cheesecake with cheesecake glaze

February 2021

  • Chocolate raspberry truffle coated in raspberry sugar dust 

March 2021

  • Key lime pie, lime glaze, graham cracker crumble

April 2021

  • Maple-bacon-bourbon, featuring west fork whiskey and smoking goose bacon

May 2021

  • Strawberry rhubarb with Big Lug sour beer glaze 

June 2021

  • Lemon poppyseed with fresh squeezed lemon glaze

July 2021

  • Crunch berry, filled mixed berry compote and dusted in captain crunch sugar 

August 2021

  • Indiana sweet corn: local corn jam, dusted in corn sugar

September 2021

  • Peach cobbler with brown sugar oat crumble